Home

A2L Item 005

Meta-Information
Description: 
A baseball is shot into the air; compare its acceleration at different times on a picture.
Goal: 
Honing the idea of constant acceleartion.
Level: 
Middle School
Keywords: 
Acceleration
Keywords: 
Mechanics
Source: 
UMPERG

A baseball is shot into the air from a spring loaded cannon. The diagram shows the ball at five locations. At which location is the magnitude of the acceleration least?

  1. Position A
  2. Position B
  3. Position C
  4. Position D
  5. Position E
  6. Position B and D
  7. Position A and E
  8. None of the Above
  9. Cannot be Determined
Commentary

Answer

The ball’s acceleration is 9.8 m/s2 (down) throughout its entire motion (assuming air resistance can be neglected). Answer (8) is the best choice.

Background

Students should have some experience analyzing the velocity of objects undergoing free-fall motion. Issues to consider: (1) Do students think that the acceleration is zero at the maximum height, where the ball momentarily stops? (2) Do students think that the acceleration points in the same direction as the velocity? (3) Can students apply the definition of acceleration to a familiar situation?

The goal is to have students confront existing misconceptions: 1) Students often believe that the acceleration must point in the direction of the motion; and 2) Students often believe that the acceleration is 9.8 throughout free fall but zero at the top of the trajectory since the vertical speed is zero there.

Questions to Reveal Student Reasoning

  • What is the acceleration of the ball on the way up? What is the direction of the acceleration? Is the acceleration changing?
  • What is the acceleration of the ball on the way down? What is the direction of the acceleration? Is the acceleration changing?
  • How can you determine whether the acceleration is zero at the maximum height? Is the velocity of the ball changing at the maximum height?
  • What causes this acceleration?

Suggestions

Ask students to apply the operational definition of acceleration (take the velocity vector just after C and subtract the velocity vector just before C and divide by the time interval). Have them compare the x/y component of the velocity just before C with the x/y component of the velocity just after point C.

For students who persist in thinking that both the velocity and acceleration are zero at the top of a trajectory, contrast the subsequent motion with that of an object sitting at rest on a surface.